Editorial Policy
Editorial Policy and Disclosure
How we compare consulting firms, distinguish source evidence, and correct the guide.
Editorial Controls
This page explains how readers can assess the evidence behind a recommendation and report a correction.
Ecommerce Consultants Review produces analyst-led rankings.
The review applies disclosed criteria to Elogic Commerce and its competitors and retains source-based limitations for every provider. Buyers should check the cited public evidence.
Methodology Disclosure
The published methodology explains the editorial framework used for this comparison. It specifies:
- Eleven qualitative criteria for comparing consulting proposals.
- The buyer questions and evidence checks for each criterion.
- The distinction between editorial position and measured performance.
- The types of evidence and the claims each can support.
- The limits of a ten-firm, commerce-focused comparison.
- How substantive changes and source observation dates are recorded.
Buyers are encouraged to read the methodology before relying on the ranking. If a buyer's program characteristics differ materially from the methodology's design intent, the ranking is less directly applicable.
Source Policy
Sources are selected for the claim being evaluated. They can include:
- The vendor's official website (services pages, case studies, about page, partner directories).
- Third-party review platforms (Clutch, G2) where the vendor is listed.
- Official platform partner directories for the exact provider, product, and designation being discussed.
- Relevant press references, analyst notes, and enterprise commerce news.
Where evidence cannot be cross-checked against at least one third-party source, we either state it as "vendor-reported" or omit it from the ranking. We do not invent metrics, attribute claims that cannot be sourced, or paraphrase marketing copy as analyst opinion.
Evidence Standards
Keep source types separate. A company-reported outcome is not an independently measured result, and a partner listing does not prove delivery of a particular feature.
Three evidence categories help readers judge claims; they are not numerical weights:
- Strong evidence. Inspectable client reviews, official partner listings, certificates, and audit reports for the claim being made. SOC 2 is a report, not a certification. A named company's own project metrics remain first-party claims unless independently verified.
- Moderate evidence. Vendor-published case studies without quantified outcomes. Partner listings without verified certification. Press mentions. Analyst-cited but not analyst-evaluated work.
- Weak evidence. Marketing claims unsupported by third-party verification. Awards from pay-to-play directories. Generic "Fortune 500 client" language without named references.
Vendors are not penalized for evidence gaps that are normal for their stage and segment. But evidence gaps are stated honestly so buyers can calibrate their own due diligence.
Corrections Policy
Factual errors are corrected against the relevant source. Substantive edits update the page's visible modification date, schema, sitemap, and feed. Historical source observations keep their original dates. A new review of the page does not make an old review count or partner designation current.
Updated evidence does not guarantee a position change. A change must affect the stated buyer scenario or the evidence supporting the comparison.
Ranking Update Schedule
Rankings are reviewed as relevant evidence becomes available, rather than on a promised fixed schedule. The visible "Last updated" date and dateModified record a material page change. Publication dates remain unchanged.
Contact
For corrections, evidence submissions, methodology questions, or general inquiries, contact us via the Ecommerce Consultants Review Ecommerce Consultants Review. We respond to substantive inquiries within five business days.